360 feedback in personal coaching: when the coachee’s own view is not enough
In personal coaching, almost everything the coach knows about the coachee comes from the coachee: what their manager is like, what happened in the last meeting, why they were not promoted, what their team thinks of them. It is an honest account, but it is an account. And a development plan built only on it has a clear limit: it cannot include what the coachee does not see in themselves.
A 360 adds the missing perspective. In a company it is usually part of a programme; personal coaching is different, because nobody else commissions it. Here we explain why it is worth it and how to set it up well when the coachee comes on their own.
What the coach cannot see
The coach sees the coachee in sessions: attentive, reflective, keen to change. That is exactly the setting where they behave best. What the coach does not see is how they react when a colleague disagrees, how they give instructions in a hurry or how they listen to a difficult client.
The coachee does not fully see it either. Self-assessment is inaccurate in almost every field (Dunning, Heath and Suls, 2004), and in leadership behaviours the gap between how people rate themselves and how others rate them is common and has consequences: those who rate themselves well above what others see tend to perform worse (Fleenor et al., 2010).
The Johari window (Luft and Ingham, 1955) sums it up. There is what the coachee and others know, what only the coachee knows, what only others see and what nobody sees. Coaching sessions work the first two quadrants very well. The third, the blind spot, only opens up by asking others.
How it differs from a 360 in a company
The tool is the same, but the context changes in four ways worth being clear about before you start:
- The coachee asks for it, not a company. Nobody forces them, so motivation is usually high. But they may also be tempted to ask only people who will agree with them.
- They may not have a current team or manager. Someone changing jobs, starting a business or working freelance does not have the classic split of manager, peers and direct reports. Groups have to be built around who actually sees them work.
- The report belongs to them. No HR or management reads it. That gives a lot of room for candour, and raters should be told so.
- What is worked on depends on the coaching goal. In a company the questionnaire usually comes from a competency model. In personal coaching it is built from what the coachee wants to change.
How to set it up, step by step
- Start from the coaching goal. If the coachee wants to "have more presence in meetings", ask about behaviours that show in a meeting: whether they present their ideas clearly, whether they hold their position when there is disagreement, whether they let others speak. Between 10 and 20 behaviours is usually enough; an 80-question survey tires people out and dilutes what matters.
- Decide the groups with the coachee. Ask who sees them work up close: current or recent colleagues, a former manager, clients, partners, people they coordinate. Group them by type of relationship, because each group sees different behaviours.
- Let them propose the names and review the list yourself. They know who to ask; you can spot whether everyone is like-minded or whether someone who has seen them at a difficult moment is missing. A 360 with only friends confirms rather than informs.
- Mind the minimum per group. So that nobody feels identifiable, each anonymous group needs at least 3 responses. If a group falls short, it is better to combine it with another than to leave it with two people. We explain it in how to keep a 360 review anonymous.
- Tell raters what it is for. Let them know it is for the coachee's development, that nobody else will see their individual answers and that candour is more useful than kindness. A short message from the coachee asking for their help works better than a generic email.
- Prepare the debrief before showing the report. Read the report before the coachee does and decide where to start. The most useful thing is usually the gap between their self-assessment and the average of others: where they see themselves better than others do (blind spot) and where they see themselves worse (hidden strength).
- Close with two or three goals. Concrete and tied to behaviours in the report. And agree from the start when you will repeat the 360 to check whether others notice the change, usually between six months and a year later.
Common mistakes
- Running the 360 at the end, as an evaluation of the process. Its greatest value is at the beginning, when the focus of the coaching can still change.
- Handing over the report without a session. A blind spot read alone, at night and without context, tends to trigger defensiveness rather than reflection. Support makes the difference: in a study of more than a thousand managers, those who reviewed their 360 with a coach set more specific goals and improved more in the next one (Smither et al., 2003).
- Trying to explain every comment. The coachee will tend to ask "who said this?". Steer the conversation from the start: what matters is the pattern, not the author.
- Working on everything. A 360 report always brings up more than can be worked on. Choosing is part of the coach's job.
How it works with Refleko
Refleko is designed so a coach can run this process without spreadsheets:
- You build the questionnaire with the behaviours that fit the goal, from the behaviour bank or with your own, and define and name the rater groups.
- The coachee can suggest who to ask, and you review the list before any invitation goes out.
- Raters answer from a private link, without creating an account, in English or Spanish. Before they start, they see whether their answer will carry their name or be anonymous.
- Each anonymous group needs at least 3 responses to be shown separately, and no figure in the report lets anyone work out who said what.
- The report shows the self-assessment against the average of others, by competency and by behaviour, with blind spots and hidden strengths already flagged.
- You publish it to the coachee, who reads it with their link and decides whether to share it with anyone else. You agree goals in the report itself, and in the next cycle Refleko compares the two reports.
The first review is free, so you can try it with your next coachee.
Frequently asked questions
Can the coachee choose who to ask?
Yes, and in personal coaching that is the norm: nobody knows better who sees them up close. The coach should review the list so that it is not only like-minded people and every group reaches the minimum number of responses.
How many raters does a personal coaching 360 need?
Between 8 and 12 is usually enough, split into two or three groups. What matters is that every anonymous group gets at least 3 responses; otherwise it is combined with another one or not shown.
Who sees the report in personal coaching?
The coachee and their coach. There is no company or HR involved, unless the coachee decides to share it with someone.
Can friends or family answer?
They can, if the coaching goal is about how the coachee relates to people outside work. But if the goal is professional, the people who see them work matter more: colleagues, former managers, clients or partners.
In short
In personal coaching, the coach works with the coachee's version, and that version leaves out exactly what they do not see. A well set-up 360, with carefully chosen raters, groups that protect anonymity and a supported debrief, gives the process a starting point that does not depend on a single account.
To continue with the series:
- Why do it: what do you base your decision on.
- So that people answer candidly: how to keep a 360 review anonymous.
- If you do executive coaching: how to use a 360 with goals the company can see too. (Coming soon)
References
- Dunning, D., Heath, C. and Suls, J. M. (2004). Flawed self-assessment: Implications for health, education, and the workplace. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 5(3), 69–106.
- Fleenor, J. W., Smither, J. W., Atwater, L. E., Braddy, P. W. and Sturm, R. E. (2010). Self–other rating agreement in leadership: A review. The Leadership Quarterly, 21(6), 1005–1034.
- Luft, J. and Ingham, H. (1955). The Johari window, a graphic model of interpersonal awareness. Proceedings of the Western Training Laboratory in Group Development. Los Angeles: UCLA.
- Smither, J. W., London, M., Flautt, R., Vargas, Y. and Kucine, I. (2003). Can working with an executive coach improve multisource feedback ratings over time? A quasi-experimental field study. Personnel Psychology, 56(1), 23–44.
Let’s talk
Planning a 360 for your team or your clients and want to clear up questions first? Write to us at hello@refleko.com or through our contact page.