What do you base your decision on? Why do a 360 review
Almost everyone wants to improve something about how they work: communicate better, delegate more, listen before answering. What almost nobody asks is something else: who decided that this is what needs improving, and on what basis?
The answer matters more than it seems. If the basis is poor, you can spend a year working on a behaviour others don’t see as a problem, while the one that really holds you back stays untouched. A 360 review is, above all, a way to change that basis.
How people decide today which behaviour to change
Without a 360, the decision usually comes from one of these five places. None of them is bad in itself, but each has a clear limit:
- The manager’s opinion in the annual review. It’s a valuable perspective, but it’s only one, and from above. There are behaviours a manager barely sees: how you treat your team when they’re not around, or how you work with other departments.
- Your own perception. It’s the natural starting point, and exactly where the blind spots are. You won’t pick as a goal what you can’t see in yourself. Research also shows we assess ourselves rather inaccurately: the link between how we rate ourselves and how we actually perform tends to be weak (Dunning, Heath and Suls, 2004).
- Whatever happened last. A meeting that went badly or a recent comment weighs more than months of work. It’s human, but it turns an anecdote into a plan.
- This year’s training. The leadership or communication course the company offers everyone alike. It may be useful, but it doesn’t start from what each person needs.
- The coach’s intuition. A good coach picks up a lot in a few sessions, but only sees what the coachee tells them and how the coachee behaves with them. They don’t see how that person behaves with others day to day.
They all share the same problem: they decide what to change from a single perspective.
And a single perspective is wrong more often than it seems. A classic meta-analysis by Harris and Schaubroeck (1988) found that self-ratings agree only moderately with manager or peer ratings, while managers and peers agree with each other much more. In other words, other people tend to agree on how they see you, and you’re the one furthest from that picture.
What changes when you decide with a 360
A 360 review brings together the perspectives of people who work with you from different positions: your manager, your peers, your team and, where it makes sense, clients or other relationships. On top of that comes your self-assessment. This changes the basis for the decision in three ways:
- Several perspectives instead of one. If three direct reports agree on something your manager doesn’t see, it’s no longer an isolated impression.
- Specific behaviours, not labels. The question isn’t whether someone “is a good leader”, but how often they do observable things, such as explaining the reasons behind their decisions or asking for input before settling them. A specific behaviour can be worked on; a label can’t.
- The gap between how you see yourself and how others see you. It’s the most valuable part of the report. Where you rate yourself well above others, there’s a blind spot; where you rate yourself well below, a hidden strength.
An example: someone gives themselves 5 out of 5 on communication and the others give them 3.2 on average. On collaboration they give themselves 2.7 and the others 4.2. Without the 360, this person would probably choose to work on collaboration, where they see themselves as weakest. With the 360, the starting point is different: communication, where others notice something they don’t see.
That shift in priority is the main reason to do a 360.
What a 360 doesn’t do on its own
It’s worth being honest: receiving a report doesn’t change anyone. The most cited study on the subject, a meta-analysis by Smither, London and Reilly published in 2005 in Personnel Psychology, pooled 24 studies that measured the same people before and after a 360. The average improvement in ratings was small. It’s not an isolated finding: an earlier meta-analysis of feedback in general (Kluger and DeNisi, 1996) found that feedback improves performance on average, but made it worse in more than a third of cases.
The interesting part is why. The authors found that improvement is much more likely when several conditions are met: the report makes clear that change is needed, the person accepts it instead of getting defensive, believes change is possible, sets specific goals and acts on them.
Support, in particular, makes a measurable difference. In a study of 1,202 managers at a multinational who did two 360s a year apart, those who reviewed their report with a coach set more specific goals, asked their managers for more improvement ideas and got better ratings from their direct reports and managers in the second 360. And that was with only two or three coaching sessions (Smither et al., 2003).
Put another way, a 360 doesn’t replace development work; it gives it a better starting point. What makes the difference is what happens next:
- a well-run debrief, where the person understands the report and isn’t just left with the blow;
- two or three specific goals, not ten;
- someone to support the process, whether a coach or a manager;
- a second 360 some time later to check whether others notice the change.
Without that, a 360 stays an interesting report. With it, it becomes the way to decide what to change and to check whether it has changed.
When not to run a 360
A badly set-up 360 can do more harm than not running one. Better to wait or look for another tool in these cases:
- If it’s tied to pay, promotions or dismissals. As soon as something is at stake, raters stop answering candidly and the person being reviewed stops listening. A 360 works as a development tool, not a judgement.
- In the middle of an open conflict. The answers will reflect the conflict, not everyday behaviour, and the report can be used as a weapon.
- If nobody is going to do anything with the result. Asking ten people for their opinion and doing nothing with it wears down trust for next time.
- If the group is so small that anonymity can’t be guaranteed. With two direct reports, anonymity isn’t possible. We explain it in detail in why everything depends on the trust of those who answer.
Frequently asked questions
What’s the difference between a 360 and a performance review?
A performance review measures results and is usually done by the manager, often with consequences for pay or promotion. A 360 gathers how several people see you on specific behaviours, and its goal is development. They complement each other, but mixing them spoils both.
What is a 360 review for?
To decide which behaviours to work on using data from several sources instead of a single opinion. And, repeated later, to check whether others notice the change.
How often should you run a 360?
Once enough time has passed to change behaviours and for others to notice. Repeating it after a few weeks only measures noise. That second 360, run after a development plan to measure the change, is sometimes called a 720 review.
In short
The question isn’t whether to do a 360, but on what basis you decide what to change. A single perspective, however good, leaves out exactly what you can’t see. A well-run 360, followed by goals and support, gives you a better starting point and a way to check progress.
Depending on where you stand, this series continues with:
- If you’re a coach: how to use a 360 in personal coaching. (Coming soon)
- If you do executive coaching: how to use a 360 with goals the company also sees. (Coming soon)
- If you’re thinking of doing a 360 yourself: what you learn about how others see you. (Coming soon)
- So that people answer candidly: how to keep 360 feedback anonymous.
References
- Dunning, D., Heath, C. and Suls, J. M. (2004). Flawed self-assessment: Implications for health, education, and the workplace. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 5(3), 69–106.
- Harris, M. M. and Schaubroeck, J. (1988). A meta-analysis of self-supervisor, self-peer, and peer-supervisor ratings. Personnel Psychology, 41(1), 43–62.
- Kluger, A. N. and DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254–284.
- Smither, J. W., London, M., Flautt, R., Vargas, Y. and Kucine, I. (2003). Can working with an executive coach improve multisource feedback ratings over time? A quasi-experimental field study. Personnel Psychology, 56(1), 23–44.
- Smither, J. W., London, M. and Reilly, R. R. (2005). Does performance improve following multisource feedback? A theoretical model, meta-analysis, and review of empirical findings. Personnel Psychology, 58(1), 33–66.
Let’s talk
Planning a 360 for your team or your clients and want to clear up questions first? Write to us at hello@refleko.com or through our contact page.